Skip to main content
Back to the Journal

Opal in Silver or Gold: Which Metal Suits Your Opal Jewellery?

Silver and gold both suit opal, but they wear, look and age differently. Here is how to choose the right metal for your stone and the way you live.

Jewellery · By Stephanie Caruana ·

Crystal Black Opal Ring – Gemini Ring

Opal looks beautiful in both silver and gold, so the choice comes down to how the piece will be worn, the colour of the opal and your budget. Sterling silver is softer and tarnishes but is affordable and bright. Gold is harder wearing and does not tarnish, which makes it the safer choice for a ring worn every day.

Does opal look better in silver or gold?

Neither metal is better for every opal; it's about contrast and taste. Cool metals tend to suit pale opal, and warm metals tend to flatter dark opal, but plenty of beautiful pieces break that rule.

Some pairings I often come back to:

  • White and light opal (body tone N7 to N9) looks clean and airy in sterling silver or white gold.
  • Black opal (N1 to N4) and dark semi-black opal can glow against yellow gold, which picks up the reds and oranges in the play of colour.
  • Boulder opal, with its brown ironstone, often sits warmly in yellow or rose gold.
  • Crystal opal is see-through, so the metal behind it shows. For small solid crystal stones, I recommend darkening the setting behind the stone to lift the colour, whichever metal you choose.

The best test is to hold the stone against each metal in daylight. Opal changes with the light, and so does the way it reads against silver or gold.

What is the difference between sterling silver and gold?

Sterling silver is 92.5 per cent silver, which is why it's stamped 925. Gold is sold by karat: 9ct is 37.5 per cent gold, 14ct is 58.5 per cent and 18ct is 75 per cent, with the rest made up of other metals.

Sterling silver

Silver is the most affordable precious metal for opal jewellery and has a bright, white shine. It's softer than most gold alloys, so it shows scratches and wear sooner, and it tarnishes. Tarnish is just the metal reacting with the air, and it polishes off.

Gold

Gold doesn't tarnish, and the alloys used in jewellery are harder wearing than silver. It comes in yellow, white and rose. White gold is often plated with rhodium for a brighter white, and that plating can wear and need redoing over time. Some white gold alloys contain nickel, which some people react to, so ask if you have sensitive skin.

Which metal is better for an opal ring worn every day?

For a ring worn daily, gold is generally the more durable choice. Opal is soft for a gem, around 5.5 to 6.5 on the Mohs scale, so the metal has to do a lot of the protecting.

A ring takes knocks that earrings and pendants never see. In silver, thin claws can bend or wear down more readily, which puts the stone at risk. If you love silver for a daily ring, choose a sturdier design:

  1. Use a full bezel (a rim of metal around the stone) rather than fine claws.
  2. Keep the band a decent thickness, so it holds its shape.
  3. Choose a solid opal rather than a doublet or triplet for a ring worn often.
  4. Have the setting checked now and then, especially after a hard knock.

Silver is a great choice for earrings, pendants and rings worn less often. Our own ranges have included solid crystal opal and opalised fossil shell set in 925 silver.

How do you care for opal in silver and in gold?

Care for the opal first and the metal second. Opal doesn't like hard knocks, harsh chemicals or sudden temperature changes, and doublets and triplets shouldn't be soaked, because water can weaken the glue layer.

For silver, keep the piece in its box or a pouch when you're not wearing it, which slows tarnish. If it starts to look brown or dull, buff it with a jewellery polishing cloth and it returns to a high shine. That's why I've included a polishing cloth and care sheet with jewellery orders.

For gold, a soft brush and lukewarm water with a little mild soap is enough for the metal, but keep doublets and triplets out of water. Avoid ultrasonic cleaners and steam cleaners for any opal jewellery.

Does the metal change the cost of opal jewellery?

Yes. The metal is a real part of what a piece costs to make, and gold costs far more than silver. Higher karat gold costs more again.

That's why many people choose a better opal in silver rather than a lesser one in gold, or start with silver and reset the stone in gold later. A well-cut opal can be moved to a new setting; a poor stone won't be improved by expensive metal.

Workmanship differs too. Gold is lovely to work, too. As I posted recently, engraving on gold is so satisfying, and a lot easier than silver if you ask me.

How do you choose the right metal for your opal?

Choose by wear first, then colour, then budget. A ring worn every day points toward gold and a protective setting. Earrings or a pendant leave you free to pick on looks.

  • Wearing it daily? Gold, with a bezel.
  • Pale opal and a cool look? Silver or white gold.
  • Dark or boulder opal? Try it against yellow gold.
  • On a budget? Put the money into the opal and set it in silver.

Browse opal rings to see how different stones sit in metal, or look at loose crystal opal if you're planning a piece. For something made to your brief, see our custom design service. If you make jewellery yourself, my top 10 opal jewellery making tips cover settings in more detail.

Questions people ask

Is opal better in silver or gold?

Both work. Gold is more durable and doesn't tarnish, so it suits rings worn every day; silver is affordable and looks lovely with pale opal, especially in earrings and pendants.

Does sterling silver damage opal?

No. The metal doesn't harm the stone, but silver is softer than gold, so a silver setting can wear or bend sooner and needs checking.

What gold is best for an opal ring?

Any karat can work. Lower karats such as 9ct are harder and cost less, while higher karats such as 18ct have a richer colour. A protective setting matters more than the karat.

Can you reset an opal from silver into gold?

Usually, yes. A jeweller can remove the opal and set it in a new mount, although care is needed because opal can chip.

Does white opal look good in yellow gold?

It can. Yellow gold warms a white opal and makes the setting stand out, while silver or white gold gives a cooler, softer look.